Lutron Caséta Smart Dimmer Switch
Representative image (stock photo); not the exact product.
Switches Instead Of Bulbs
The default approach to smart lighting is a smart bulb in every fitting, which in a room with six downlights means six smart bulbs and six times the cost.
A smart dimmer switch makes the whole circuit smart at once, using ordinary dimmable bulbs. For multi-bulb fittings that is substantially cheaper and it is one device to maintain rather than six.
It also means the wall switch remains a wall switch that everybody in the house can use correctly, which is the thing smart bulbs get wrong and which causes most household friction with smart lighting.
Reliability Above Everything
Lutron uses its own radio protocol rather than Wi-Fi, Zigbee or Thread, operating on a frequency with little congestion. The result is the most reliable response in smart lighting, and that is the entire argument for the system.
A light switch is the household device with the least tolerance for failure. Nobody accepts a switch that works nineteen times out of twenty, because the expectation set by a hundred years of ordinary switches is absolute.
The proprietary protocol is a genuine drawback for openness and it is why the reliability is what it is, and for a switch specifically that trade is the right way round.
Installation Means Wiring
This replaces a wall switch, which means working with mains wiring. In some regions that is a normal householder task and in others it requires a qualified electrician, and the honest answer is to use one if there is any doubt.
It also needs the right wiring configuration, and installations without a neutral wire at the switch need a specific compatible model. Checking what is in the box behind your switch before ordering is essential.
Once installed it is permanent infrastructure needing no batteries and no maintenance, which is the reward for the installation effort being higher than screwing in a bulb.
Dimming Quality And Bulb Compatibility
Dimming quality is where this shows its origins as a lighting control company: smooth dimming to low levels without flicker or buzz, which cheap dimmers frequently fail at.
Bulb compatibility matters, because a non-dimmable LED in a dimmer will flicker or buzz regardless of the dimmer quality. Using genuinely dimmable bulbs is a requirement rather than a recommendation.
A hub is required for app and automation control, and the switch works as an ordinary dimmer without it, which is a sensible failure mode.
Who It Suits
This suits multi-bulb fittings, whole rooms, and any household where the wall switch needs to keep working as a wall switch for everybody.
It suits less well a rented property where wiring changes are not permitted, or anyone wanting colour lighting, which switches cannot provide.
It suits particularly well anyone who has tried smart bulbs and been frustrated by the wall switch problem, because this is the correct solution to it rather than a workaround.
The Verdict
The most reliable smart lighting control available, cheaper per room than bulbs in multi-bulb fittings, and it keeps the wall switch working correctly for everybody.
It requires mains wiring work, a hub for automation, genuinely dimmable bulbs, and it cannot do colour.
For multi-bulb rooms this is the right approach rather than smart bulbs — cheaper, one device, and the switch still behaves like a switch.
At a glance
Pros
- Makes a whole circuit smart; far cheaper for multi-bulb fittings
- Wall switch keeps working correctly for everybody
- Most reliable radio in smart lighting
- Excellent flicker-free dimming to low levels
Cons
- Requires mains wiring work, often an electrician
- Proprietary protocol rather than an open standard
- Cannot provide colour lighting
- Needs genuinely dimmable bulbs and a hub for automation
Frequently asked questions
Switches or smart bulbs?
Switches for multi-bulb fittings — one device instead of six, substantially cheaper, and the wall switch still works for everyone. Bulbs where you want colour, or in a rented property where wiring changes are not allowed.
Can I install it myself?
It replaces a wall switch, so it involves mains wiring. In some regions that is a normal householder task and in others it needs a qualified electrician — use one if there is any doubt. Also check whether there is a neutral wire at the switch.
Why a proprietary protocol?
Because it operates on a frequency with little congestion and produces the most reliable response in the category. For a light switch — the household device with the least tolerance for failure — that trade against openness is the right way round.
Specifications
| Type | Smart wall dimmer |
| Protocol | Proprietary, low congestion |
| Reliability | Highest in category |
| Coverage | Whole circuit, any dimmable bulbs |
| Physical control | Retained fully |
| Installation | Mains wiring |
| Hub | Required for automation |
| Colour | Not possible |
The bottom line
Cheaper per room than bulbs, the most reliable radio in the category, and the switch still behaves like a switch. It needs wiring work.
Check Price on Amazon